Compare and contrast two EBP models.
Question description1) Compare and contrast two EBP models.
2) Discuss which would most likely work in your agency or clinical unit.
3) Explain why one model would work better than the other with your colleages or you organizational culture.
4) Supports your answer with reference
YOU CAN PICK TWO OF THE FOLLOWING:
1)ACE Star Model
2) ARRC Model
3) Iowa Model
4) Johns Hopkins EBP Model
5) Stetler Model
I WORK IN URGENT CARE COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER WHERE POPULATION IS MOSTLY UNINSURED PEOPLE , HISPANIC WITH LOW INCOME LOW EDUCATIONAL LEVEL. PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF YOU NEED MORE INFO
DISCUSSION PAPER
Evidence-based practice models for organizational change: overview
and practical applications
Marjorie A. Schaffer, Kristin E. Sandau & Lee Diedrick
Accepted for publication 19 July 2012
Correspondence to M.A. Schaffer:
e-mail: m-schaffer@bethel.edu
Marjorie A. Schaffer PhD RN
Professor of Nursing
Bethel University, St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
Kristin E. Sandau PhD RN CNE
Professor of Nursing
Bethel University, St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
Lee Diedrick MAN RN C-NIC
Clinical Educator
Children’s Hospitals and Clinics of
Minnesota, St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
SCHAFFER M.A., SANDAU K.E. & DIEDRICK L. (2013) Evidence-based
practice models for organizational change: overview and practical applications. Journal
of Advanced Nursing 69(5), 1197–1209. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2012.06122.x
Abstract
Aim. To provide an overview, summary of key features and evaluation of
usefulness of six evidence-based practice models frequently discussed in the
literature.
Background. The variety of evidence-based practice models and frameworks,
complex terminology and organizational culture challenges nurses in selecting the
model that best fits their practice setting.
Data sources. The authors: (1) initially identified models described in a
predominant nursing text; (2) searched the literature through CINAHL from
1998 to current year, using combinations of ‘evidence’, ‘evidence-based practice’,
‘models’, ‘nursing’ and ‘research’; (3) refined the list of selected models based on
the initial literature review; and (4) conducted a second search of the literature on
the selected models for all available years to locate both historical and recent
articles on their use in nursing practice.
Discussion. Authors described model key features and provided an evaluation of
model usefulness based on specific criteria, which focused on facilitating the
evidence-based practice process and guiding practice change.
Implications for nursing. The evaluation of model usefulness can be used to
determine the best fit of the models to the practice setting.
Conclusion. The Johns Hopkins Model and the Academic Center for EvidenceBased
Practice Star Model emphasize the processes of finding and evaluating
evidence that is likely to appeal to nursing educators. Organizations may prefer
the Promoting Action on Research Implementation in Health Services
Framework, Advancing Research and Clinical Practice Through Close
Collaboration, or Iowa models for their emphasis on team decision-making. An
evidence-based practice model that is clear to the clinician and fits the
organization will guide a systematic approach to evidence review and practice
change.
Keywords: evidence-based practice, nursing education, nursing models, research
in practice
