1. Who was the most reliable witness? Explain and defend your answer using your eyewitness reliability criteria.

(1.)

1. Who was the most reliable witness? Explain and defend your answer using your eyewitness reliability criteria.

I think that Admir Adjinj is the most reliable eyewitness because he was familiar enough with his neighbor to recognize him immediately making his eyewitness identification more likely to be accurate. Unlike others who identified the man with the woman to be a large African male Admir Adjinj was already familiar enough with the man to know exactly who he was. Another factor that makes him more reliable is that he hadn’t been partaking in alcoholic activates making his ability to recall information more reliable. Many other witnesses had fuzzy interpretations of the events because they were under the influence of alcohol. A third reason I think he is the most reliable witness is because of his close proximity to the crime, He not only identified the perpetrator but he was close enough to the action that his eyewitness testimony would seem more appropriate. One could argue that Angelica Sanchez was the closest witness however as an intimate member of the group in question, she was close to the members of this group, and there was enough people in the group to influence her decision. which according to the social impact theory means that there influence likely impacted her perception.

2. Describe what other aspects of the case might influence juror perceptions and judgments besides the immediate evidence at hand.

When first reading about this case my initial schema was that there are many jocks that have been accused of this kind of behavior as well as movies that often portrays the villain to be the in the circle with the jocks and other mean popular students. Because of my existing schemas my first automatic thought was that he was in fact guilty meaning that others may also come to these conclusions without realizing the impact that their current schemas and/or automatic thought process have. Another aspect I think might influence the jury is wither or not the just world beliefs theory comes to play. The victim was drunk, and the football player dose seem to be in the in-crowd so the jury may resort to victim blaming to feel more in control of these terrible circumstances. The third aspect I think might influence the jurors are the other jurors. As we have noticed in chapter 8 there are consequences to resisting to the groups believes which may present the case of public compliance. However, because the issue at hand is so important would not people instead to choose to stick to their guns. According to high importance conditions this would make the jury more susceptible to conform with the group’s decision causing a greater probability that they will conform to the decision wright or wrong. Not all influence on the juries are bad, because the two lawyers will both be arguing different sides the role of informational social influence may react as a positive. like the participants in Milgrams study, when the two authority figures began to argue, the two authoritative lawyers may help round the jurors mindset back to thinking what is right or wrong in their own terms without conforming to the group.

(2)

1. Who was the most credible witness? Explain and defend your answer using your eyewitness reliability criteria.

I think Angelica Sanchez is the most reliable witness. She is the girlfriend of Ronald Darby who is not only one of Jameis Winston’s football friends, but he also accompanied Mr. Winston the night of the incident. Angelica is familiar with “the boys” and was also in the apartment the night of the incident. She mentioned that the female accompanying Mr. Winston appeared drunk with red eyes and was wobbly. Angelica further mentions that Mr. Winston immediately led the woman back to his bedroom. This goes against Chris’s account that the woman accompanying Mr. Winston was not intoxicated and willingly followed Mr. Winston into his apartment and bedroom. Angelica was not at the bar that night and said she came to the apartment after receiving a phone call from Ronald asking her to come over. When there she watched a show on TV. She never mentioned drinking alcohol. Angelica was the only witness who viewed the scene under the most favorable of conditions as she was right there in the apartment when they entered and was not under the influence of any substances nor under duress at the time.

I was concerned that she did not hear the assault happening after learning Mr. Winston’s door does not close fully. But it is difficult to discern where exactly Mr. Winston’s bedroom is located in the apartment, how many bedrooms are in the apartment, and how close his room was to her location in the living room. Additionally, after re-reading the description of the assault, I noticed that the victim claimed she attempted to push him off. Nowhere in her statement did she say she screamed for help. Angelica also states that both Ronald and Chris were back in the hall laughing and she just assumed that Jameis and the other woman were having “drunken sex”. Twice in her account she mentions the word back in relation to Jameis’s bedroom. This leads me to believe his bedroom must be at the end of a hall. I also feel that any commotion she would have heard she would have attributed it to “drunken sex” and would not feel alerted.

Another concern of mine was that maybe she did not like Chris and purposefully made claims that went against his eyewitness account which would make others question the validity of his account. Yet if she were to purposefully do this, her boyfriend Ronald would also be in trouble as she mentioned hearing both Chris and Ronald laughing down the hall while assuming Jameis and the other woman were having drunken sex. In saying this she has just made her boyfriend a witness to the assault. If she truly loves her boyfriend, she would be more biased to protect him and not wrap him up in the ordeal. All in all I feel her eyewitness account is much more reliable than the others.

2. Describe what other aspects of the case might influence juror perceptions and judgments besides the immediate evidence at hand.

Mr. Winston is described as a redshirt freshman quarterback and a “prized recruit”. He was given this redshirt year to help prepare himself for the upcoming football season and being that he was a prized recruit, there is no way that the football program would want to lose him before they could witness his full potential. This became more evident when we are made aware that the University of Florida broke the law when it failed to investigate the incident after becoming aware of it. Jurors familiar with college football, would know this as well and could be swayed in their perceptions and judgements of Mr. Winston. College football is big in the south and it would not be the first time preference was given to a football player in order to ensure a secure future for a college football program. Some jurors who may be avid fans of the team or alumni may not want to lose a player with such potential and may be swayed to do what is needed in order to keep Jameis on the team. There are too many opportunities for bias to occur in this equation.

The victim was a minor at a bar who shared quite a few alcoholic beverages with her friends. She also consumed a beverage that was handed to her by a stranger and later gave her number to a man she had just met. All of this would make her look careless and irresponsible. Some jurors may consider her behavior reckless and stereotype her based on her actions. This could lead them to question the validity of her claims. Unfortunately, this also leaves room for belief in a just world as some jurors may believe the assault was a result of her behavior and actions.

IN 5-6 LINES RESPONSE THIS TWO DISCUSSION BOARD. When responding to others it is best to add support to their claims or add evidence or logic that goes against their claims.