Motivating Employees

Midterm Case Study: Motivating Employees
Due Week
Imagine that you have been appointed the Director of Health at the Kaluyu Memorial Hospital in Nairobi, Kenya – a for-profit hospital. The facility is also a referral hospital and receives severe cases of accidents, chronicle / communicable diseases, and houses an HIV / AIDS ward. As you settle into your position, you realize that the employees always act scared as they approach their superiors. Some of the employees even deliver files and leave your office in a hurry.
As you make your routine departmental visits, you realize that there are tensions between nurses and doctors, and there is a sentiment that the nurses tend to do the majority of the work within patient care but the doctors get all the credit. You realize that the employees are always looking forward to the end of their shifts to go home. Some employees even come back to work wearing the same unwashed clothes as the previous day. Too many employees are calling in sick, and many of them give weak reasons for their tardiness.
There is also a sense that employees and nurses dominate other employees in similar positions. In meetings and conference calls, some employees are always quiet and never participate. You notice that people with families tend to gather and talk quietly on breaks. The new mothers working for the hospital have to use bathrooms to pump breast milk for their infants and the refrigerators do not work well. Looking at the financial statements of the hospital, you realize that the hospital expenses are higher than the industry standard, and it makes losses year after year.
Note: You may create and / or make all necessary assumptions needed for the completion of this assignment.
Write a four to six (4-6) page paper in which you:

  1. Investigate the major      demotivational factors at Kaluyu Memorial Hospital. Assess the level of impact      that the identified factors could have on specific areas of service and      business if the administration does not address the situation. Support      your response with at least two (2) examples of the potential negative      impact of the identified demotivational factors on the hospital.
  2. Choose Maslow’s,      Herzberg’s, or McClelland’s model of motivation, and argue the primary      reasons why it is applicable to the Kaluyu Memorial Hospital scenario.
  3. Formulate a communication      system that will have the greatest impact on improving the situation, and specify      the major reasons why your system will influence the employee behaviors      for the better. Justify your response.
  4. Use four (4)      recent (within the last five [5] years) quality academic resources in this      assignment. Note: Wikipedia and      other websites do not qualify as quality academic resources.

Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:

  • Be typed, double      spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all      sides; citations and references must follow APA or school-specific format.      Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
  • Include a cover      page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the      professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the      reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.

Managing Health Care Quality 

Assignment 2: Managing Health Care Quality 
Due Week 8
Imagine that you are a hospital administrator at the Sunlight Hospital in California. The main complaint among the patients is the quality of care. Your job is to understand the state of the hospital, create value, increase efficiency, and turn the facility into a local hospital of choice. Whenever you are making visits in various wards to meet the employees and the patients, you hear how the patients love the hospital, but they would like to see certain improvements in care. The employees seem to be very busy executing their duties and not interacting much with the patients. The hospital board has asked you to compile a report of your findings and suggested strategy for achieving the hospital’s current goals.
Note: You may create and / or make all necessary assumptions needed for the completion of this assignment.
Write a four to six (4-6) page paper in which you:

  1. Classify five (5) measurements      of quality of care in a hospital, and justify the major reasons why you believe      these measurements matter to patients in their process of choosing a      hospital for emergency or inpatient care.
  2. Specify four (4)      main features in health care organizations that can be used to design a      successful quality improvement plan. Articulate the significant manner in      which the specified features can lead to failure or success of quality of      care in Sunlight Hospital.
  3. Suggest the      salient reasons why quality of care would add value to and create a      competitive advantage for the Sunlight Hospital. Justify your response.
  4. Use four (4)      recent (within the last five [5] years) quality academic resources in this      assignment. Note: Wikipedia and      other websites do not qualify as quality academic resources.

Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:

  • Be typed, double      spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all      sides; citations and references must follow APA or school-specific format.      Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
  • Include a cover      page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the      professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the      reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.

The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:

  • Propose      methodologies that have been proven to increase value in health care      delivery systems
  • Examine leadership      and management frameworks that are most applicable to a certain      organization type within the health care industry.
  • Craft a strategic      plan that leads to a competitive advantage within a certain market.

· Use technology and information resources to research issues in health care management.

  • Write clearly and      concisely about health care management using proper writing mechanics.

you are a senior consultant at Practical Health Care Consulting firm.

Final Case Study: Consulting for the Caring Angel Hospital
Due Week 10 and worth 300 points
Imagine that you are a senior consultant at Practical Health Care Consulting firm. Your supervisor has instructed you to spend three (3) months at the Caring Angel Hospital to help improve the quality of care, add value to the organization, improve employee morale, design an efficient organizational chart, create a strong team environment, and create the hospital’s competitive advantage. The hospital has traditionally made losses year after year. Furthermore, it is not performing well financially, and the banks are not willing to lend it large sums of money for more effective marketing.
After spending two (2) months within the hospital, you are very happy with your progress, and you think you are capable of acquiring more patient base and expanding the hospital market. However, with a closer look, you notice that your patients are still hopping from one specialized hospital to another in search of various specialized treatments. You also notice that the seats are not comfortable in the waiting area, and the patients continuously show up for appointments on the wrong dates. The nurses and the employees are not smiling during patient conversations, and everyone looks for ways to blame others for failures in the patient treatment process. Everyone seems to work alone and hide what they do from their colleagues.
At the end of the three (3) month period, you must provide a report with your recommended strategies designed to help Caring Angel Hospital achieve its goals.
Note: You may create and / or make all necessary assumptions needed for the completion of this assignment.
Write a four to six (4-6) page paper in which you:
1. From a consulting perspective, propose the major steps that Caring Angel Hospital could take to achieve each of the following goals:
a. Improve the quality of care
b. Add value to the organization
c. Improve employee morale
d. Design an efficient organizational chart
e. Create a strong team environment
f. Create the hospital’s competitive edge.
2. Recommend one (1) approach that the hospital could use for acquiring a larger market share given the prevailing financial circumstances. Justify your recommendation.
3. Investigate at least two (2) value-added services that Caring Angel Hospital could offer to strengthen its value proposition. Provide at least two (2) examples of the advantages of these value-added services to the hospital.
4. Use four (4) recent (within the last five [5] years) quality academic resources in this assignment. Note: Wikipedia and other websites do not qualify as quality academic resources.
Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:

  • Be typed, double      spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all      sides; citations and references must follow APA or school-specific format.      Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
  • Include a cover      page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the      professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the      reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.

The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:

  • Propose      methodologies that have been proven to increase value in health care      delivery systems.
  • Examine leadership      and management frameworks that are most applicable to a certain      organization type within the health care industry.

· Assess how politics in a health care organization motivates and demotivates employees, and recommend strategies to mitigate the challenges presented with each aspect.

  • Create a      communication strategy to address an ethical dilemma within a health care      organization regarding the quality of service and cost.
  • Craft a strategic      plan that leads to a competitive advantage within a certain market.

· Determine best practices for establishing and maintaining strategic alliances within the health care industry or enterprise.
· Use technology and information resources to research issues in health care management.

  • Write clearly and      concisely about health care management using proper writing mechanics.

Dashboard and Health Care Benchmark Evaluation Simulation

Preparation
For this assessment, you may choose one of the following three options for a performance dashboard to use as the basis for your benchmark evaluation.
Option 1: Dashboard and Health Care Benchmark Evaluation Simulation
If you decide to use one of the simulation dashboards for your evaluation, review both dashboards, as well as the relevant local, state, and federal laws and policies linked in each dashboard. Choose one of the dashboards and consider the metrics within it that are falling short of the prescribed benchmarks.
Review the performance dashboard for a health care organization, as well as relevant local, state, and federal laws and policies. Then, write a report for senior leaders in the organization that communicates your analysis and evaluation of the current state of organizational performance, including a recommended metric to target for improvement.
Note: Each assessment in this course builds on the work you completed in the previous assessment. Therefore, you must complete the assessments in this course in the order in which they are presented.
In the era of health care reform, many of the laws and policies set by government at the local, state, and federal levels have specific performance benchmarks related to care delivery outcomes that organizations must achieve. It is critical for organizational success that the interprofessional care team is able to understand reports and dashboards that display the metrics related to performance and compliance benchmarks. This assessment offers an opportunity for you to demonstrate and sharpen your ability to analyze, interpret, and evaluate performance dashboard metrics.
SHOW LESS
By successfully completing this assessment, you will demonstrate your proficiency in the following course competencies and assessment criteria:
· Competency 1: Analyze the effects of health care policies, laws, and regulations on organizations, interprofessional teams, and personal practice.
. Analyze challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team.
· Competency 3: Lead the development and implementation of ethical and culturally sensitive policies that improve health outcomes for individuals, organizations, and populations.
. Advocate for ethical action in addressing a benchmark underperformance, directed toward an appropriate group of stakeholders.
· Competency 4: Evaluate relevant indicators of performance, such as benchmarks, research, and best practices, for health care policies and law for patients, organizations, and populations.
. Evaluate dashboard metrics with regard to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws.
. Evaluate a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance.
· Competency 6: Apply various methods of communicating with policy makers, stakeholders, colleagues, and patients to ensure that communication in a given situation is professional, clear, efficient, and effective.
. Communicate evaluation and analysis in a professional and effective manner, writing content clearly and logically, with correct use of grammar, punctuation, and spelling.
. Integrate relevant sources to support arguments, correctly formatting citations and references using current APA style.
Competency Map
Report Requirements
Structure your report in such a way that it would be easy for a colleague or supervisor to locate the information they need. Be sure to cite relevant local, state, or federal health care laws or policies when evaluating metric performance against prescribed benchmarks. Cite an additional 2–4 credible sources to support your analysis and evaluation of the challenges in meeting the benchmarks, the potential for performance improvement, and your advocacy for ethical action.
Note: The tasks outlined below correspond to grading criteria in the scoring guide.
In your report, be sure to:
· Evaluate dashboard metrics against the benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care laws or policies.
. Which metrics are below the mandated benchmarks in the organization? Evaluate weaknesses within the entire set of benchmarks.
. What are the local, state, or federal health care laws or policies that set these benchmarks?
· Analyze challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for the organization or for an interprofessional team.
. What are the specific challenges or opportunities that the organization or interprofessional team might have in meeting the benchmarks? For example, consider:
. The strategic direction of the organization.
. The organization’s mission.
. Available resources:
. Staffing.
. Operational and capital funding.
. Physical space.
. Support services (any ancillary department that supports a specific care unit in the organization, such as a pharmacy, cleaning services, and dietary services).
· Cultural diversity in the organization.
· Cultural diversity in the community.
· Organizational processes and procedures.
· How might these challenges be contributing to benchmark underperformance?
· Evaluate a benchmark underperformance in the organization or interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance.
· Which metric is underperforming its benchmark by the greatest degree?
· Which benchmark underperformance is the most widespread throughout the organization or interprofessional team?
· Which benchmark affects the greatest number of patients?
· Which benchmark affects the greatest number of staff?
· How does this underperformance affect the community the organization serves?
· Where is the greatest opportunity for improvement in the overall quality or performance of the organization or interpersonal team—and ultimately in patient outcomes?
· Advocate for ethical action in addressing the benchmark underperformance that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance.
· At which group of stakeholders should your advocacy be directed? Which group could be expected to take the appropriate action to improve the benchmark metric?
· What are some ethical actions that the stakeholder group could take that support improved benchmark performance?
· Why should the stakeholder group take action?
· Communicate your findings and recommendations in a professional and effective manner.
· Ensure that your report is well organized and easy to read.
· Write clearly and logically, using correct grammar, punctuation, and mechanics.
· Integrate relevant sources to support your arguments, correctly formatting source citations and references using current APA style.
· Did you cite relevant local, state, or federal health care laws or policies when discussing the mandated benchmarks?
· Did you cite an additional 2–4 credible sources to support your analysis, evaluation, and advocacy?
Benchmarking and Performance Measurement Tools
This article discusses best practices in benchmarking to aid organizations in creating a plan.
· Krause, J. (2017, July 28). Four questions to ask about healthcare benchmarking. Retrieved from http://managedhealthcareexecutive.modernmedicine.com/managed-healthcare-executive/news/four-questions-ask-about-healthcare-benchmarking?page=0,0
These resources examine performance measurement tools and benchmarking used for health care delivery.
· Behrouzi, F., Shaharoun, A. M., & Ma’aram, A. (2014). Applications of the balanced scorecard for strategic management and performance measurement in the health sector. Australian Health Review, 38(2), 208–217.
· Johns Hopkins Medicine. (n.d.). Patient safety and quality. Retrieved from http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/patient_safety_quality_dashboard/understanding_performance_metrics/core_measures.html
· National Committee for Quality Assurance. (n.d.).  HEDIS and performance measurement. Retrieved from http://www.ncqa.org/hedis-quality-measurement
Performance Benchmarks Challenges and Benefits
This study outlines key barriers to measuring and benchmarking quality of mental health care, describes innovations currently underway worldwide to mitigate barriers and offers recommendations for improving quality of mental health care.
· Kilbourne, A. M., Beck, K., Spaeth‐Rublee, B., Ramanuj, P., O’Brien, R. W., Tomoyasu, N., & Pincus, H. A. (2018). Measuring and improving the quality of mental health care: A global perspective. World Psychiatry, 17(1), 30–38.
This resource discusses future options and challenges with respect to the Affordable Care Act provisions and requirements.
· RAND Corporation. (n.d.). The future of U.S. health care: Replace or revise the Affordable Care Act? Retrieved from https://www.rand.org/health/key-topics/health-policy/in-depth.html
This article explores hospital rankings in the United States and how they provide benefit to organizations and consumers in consideration of the Affordable Care Act.
· Huerta, T. R., Hefner, J. L., Ford, E. W., McAlearney, A. S., & Menachemi, N. (2014). Hospital website rankings in the United States: Expanding benchmarks and standards for effective consumer engagement. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 16(2), e64.
This article discusses key practical issues in the development of performance dashboards.
· Ghazisaeidi, M., Safdari, R., Torabi, M., Mirzaee, M., Farzi, J. & Goodini, A. (2015). Development of performance dashboards in healthcare sector: Key practical issues. Acta Informatica Medica, 23(5), 317–321.
Health Care Policies, Laws, Legislation, and Metrics
This resource explains current health care policy in the United States.
· Oliver, T. R. (Ed.). (2014).  Guide to U.S. health and health care policy . Washington, DC: CQ Press.
This article discusses the most significant reforms to the U.S. health care system as provisions and mandates in the Affordable Care Act.
· Martin, E. J. (2015). Healthcare policy legislation and administration: Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010. Journal of Health and Human Services Administration, 37(4), 407–411.
This resource discusses the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA) current payment pathways for physicians relative to quality measures and benchmarks.
· American Medical Association. (n.d.). Quality payment program specifics. Retrieved from https://www.ama-assn.org/practice-management/quality-payment-program-qpp-specifics
·
Dashboard and Health Care Benchmark Evaluation
· Introduction
· Scatterdesk
· Conclusion
Introduction
Dashboards and other reports can provide crucial information about how well an organization is meeting benchmarks set by local, state, and federal laws and policies. Healthcare organizations need to be able to use this information to determine the most effective strategies for quality and performance improvement. This activity asks you to review various dashboards and reports used by Mercy Medical Center, a Vila Health affiliated hospital, and determine where the organization is falling short.
Back to top
Scatterdesk
Voice Mail
Evelyn Unger
Senior Human Resources Generalist
Hey there. This is Evelyn Unger; sorry I missed you. I just wanted give you a little more context for the report you’ve been asked to pull together on our dashboard metrics. The main thing is that we’re trying to get a better understanding of how to evaluate the information these dashboards are providing. The goal is to be able to use the data as actionable information.
So – if you could review the materials I’ve provided to you and use one of the two dashboards as the source of the data, that would be great. You’ll need to do some external research probably in order to determine external benchmarks and standards. Oh … and remember that while there may be a couple of underperforming areas, your recommendations should be based on the actions that will deliver the best improvement to overall quality or performance.
Let me know if you have any questions.
Public Health Dashboard – Diabetes
New Patients Last Quarter by Race
· African American – 17 (3%)
· American Indian – 73 (13%)
· Asian – 34 (6%)
· White – 355 (63%)
· Other – 11 (2%)
· Blank/Declined – 73 (13%)
New Patients Last Quarter by Gender
· Male – 214 (38%)
· Female – 347 (62%)
· Blank/Declined – 2
New Patients Last Quarter by Age
· 20 or younger – 118 (21%)
· 21-44 – 51 (9%)
· 45-64 – 214 (38%)
· 65+ – 180 (32%)
· Blank/Declined – 0

  Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4 2015 Q1 2016 Q2 2016 Q3 2016 Q4 2016
Eye Exam 4 16 7 33 41 28 16 27
Foot Exam 2 5 27 48 73 62 7 3
HgbA1c 1 11 23 87 123 32 13 6

2016 Fact Sheet
Mercy Medical Center (Shakopee, MN)
Mercy Medical Center is one of the region’s top choices for high quality health care. Don’t just take our word for it though. Here are some of the accolades we’ve received:
· Highest Safe Surgery Rating by a consumer advocacy magazine.
· Healthgrades Outstanding Patient Experience Award.
· Shakopee Ledger Top 20 Workplaces 2014 & 2015.
· Women’s Choice Award for the Best Hospital for Patient Experience in Emergency Care.
Shakopee Demographics

Female Male Total Population
18,235 17,957 36,192
< 20 21-44 45-64 > 65
12,126 14,732 6,099 2,371
White Asian Hispanic – Latino Other African American Two or more races American Indian
28,537 (76%) 3,822 (10%) 2,890 (7%) 1,661 (4%) 1,601 (4%) 1,016 (4%) 433 (1%)

Shakopee Ledger
Top 20 Workplaces 2014 & 2015

  2005 2015
Hospital Rooms (All Private) 62 (70 licensed) 85 (93 licensed)
Medical / Surgical Rooms 33 56
Special Care Unit 8 8
Family Birth Rooms 17 17
Children’s Care Pediatric Rooms 4 4
Operating Rooms 5 and 1 C – Section 8 and 1 C – Section
Emergency Room Treatment Bays 16 21
Endoscopy Rooms 2 2
  2015
Physicians 433
Volunteers (15 — 94 yeard old) 200
Inpatient Admissions 5,735
Surgical Procedures 4,627
Births 1,328
Emergency Room Visits 29,893
Urgent Care Visits 9,586
Outpatient Encounters 119,535
Physical, Occupational, Speech/Language Therapy Visits 28,636
Pediatric Therapy Visits 11,987
Sleep Center Visits 783
Radiology Procedures 59,335
Cardiac Rehab Visits 7,158
Cardiopulmonary Visits 19,676
Cancer Center Visits 7,781

Hospital CEO Dashboard
Local Readmission Rates

COPD Pneumonia Heart Failure
20.1 (31%) 18.7 (29%) 26.4 (40%)

National Readmission Rates

COPD Pneumonia Heart Failure
20.2 (34%) 16.9 (29%) 22.0 (37%)

Medical & Surgery

Falls Medication Errors Pressure Sores Patient Injuries Documentation Errors
2015 = 14 / 2016 = 10 2015 = 4 / 2016 = 8 2015 = 4 / 2016 = 3 2015 = 3 / 2016 = 4 2015 = 3 / 2016 = 4

Labor & Delivery

Falls Medication Errors Pressure Sores Patient Injuries Documentation Errors
2015 = 3 / 2016 = 0 2015 = 5 / 2016 = 0 2015 = 0 / 2016 = 0 2015 = 1 / 2016 = 0 2015 = 9 / 2016 = 1

Orthopedics

Falls Medication Errors Pressure Sores Patient Injuries Documentation Errors
2015 = 8 / 2016 = 10 2015 = 2 / 2016 = 2 2015 = 5 / 2016 = 3 2015 = 4 / 2016 = 4 2015 = 4 / 2016 = 3

Bariatric Services

Falls Medication Errors Pressure Sores Patient Injuries Documentation Errors
2015 = 16 / 2016 = 18 2015 = 7 / 2016 = 7 2015 = 4 / 2016 = 3 2015 = 3 / 2016 = 1 2015 = 16 / 2016 = 23
  Average Daily Census Average Daily RN FTEs Scheduled RN FTEs
ICU 18 11 14
PICU 17 12 13.5
Med Surg 23 14 16
Labor and Delivery 16 10 10
Orthopedics 12 6.25 6.5
West 1 20 13 15.25
West 2 13 8.5 9.5
North 1 18 9.75 12.75

Back to top
Conclusion
In this activity, you had the opportunity to review various dashboards and other reports in order to evaluate Mercy Medical Center’s performance against local, state, and federal requirements. Use the information you acquired here as well as external research into appropriate standards to complete your course assignment.
Back to top
Credits
Subject Matter Expert:
Bressie, Marylee
Interactive Design:
Olson, Lori
Media Instructional Designer:
Pearson, Felicity
Instructional Designer:
Hagen, Brian
Project Manager:
Hall, Nakeela
Back to top
Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License
Dashboard Benchmark Evaluation Scoring Guide

CRITERIA NON-PERFORMANCE BASIC PROFICIENT DISTINGUISHED
Evaluate dashboard metrics with regard to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws. Does not analyze dashboard metrics with regard to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws. Analyzes dashboard metrics, but relationship to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws is missing or flawed. Evaluates dashboard metrics with regard to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws. Evaluates dashboard metrics with regard to benchmarks set by local, state, or federal health care policies or laws, and identifies knowledge gaps, unknowns, missing information, unanswered questions, or areas of uncertainty (where further information could improve the evaluation).
Analyze challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team. Does not list challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team. Lists but does not analyze challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team, or provides a flawed analysis that misses key challenges. Analyzes challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team. Analyzes challenges that meeting prescribed benchmarks can pose for a heath care organization or an interprofessional team, and identifies assumptions on which the analysis is based.
Evaluate a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance. Does not evaluate a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance. Provides a partial or flawed evaluation of a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team; misses factors that are key to understanding the potential for improving overall quality or performance. Evaluates a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance. Evaluates a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or an interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality or performance, and defends reasoning for selecting this benchmark over another with similar potential for improvement.
Advocate for ethical action in addressing a benchmark underperformance, directed toward an appropriate group of stakeholders. Does not advocate for ethical action in addressing a benchmark underperformance, directed toward an appropriate group of stakeholders. Attempts to advocate for ethical action but attempt is flawed, superficial, or does not address an appropriate group of stakeholders. Advocates for ethical action in addressing a benchmark underperformance, directed toward an appropriate group of stakeholders. Advocates for ethical action in addressing a benchmark underperformance, directed at an appropriate group of stakeholders, and recommends criteria for evaluating the effectiveness of recommended action.
Communicate evaluation and analysis in a professional and effective manner, writing content clearly and logically, with correct use of grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Does not communicate evaluation and analysis findings and recommendations in a professional and effective manner; does not write content clearly and logically, and does not use correct grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Communicates evaluation and analysis findings and recommendations that are not consistently professional, effective, clear, and logical, or that contain errors in use of grammar, punctuation, or spelling that distract from the message. Communicates evaluation and analysis in a professional and effective manner, writing content clearly and logically, with correct use of grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Communicates evaluation and analysis findings and recommendations that are professional, effective, and insightful; the content is clear, logical, and persuasive; and grammar, punctuation, and spelling are without errors.
Integrate relevant sources to support arguments, correctly formatting citations and references using current APA style. Does not integrate relevant sources to support arguments; does not correctly format citations and references using current APA style. Cites sources that lack relevance or integrates them poorly, or formats citations or references incorrectly. Integrates relevant sources to support arguments, correctly formatting citations and references using current APA style. Integrates relevant sources to support arguments, correctly formatting citations and references using current APA style. Citations are free from all errors.