PREVENTING HYPOTHERMIA IN SURGICAL PATIENT

Is forced air warmer more effective in decreasing surgical hypothermia as compared to conventional warming of surgical patients?”
 
MY PROBLEM IS PREVENTING HYPOTHERMIA IN SURGICAL PATIENT
 
 
 
Capstone Project Milestone #1:
PICO and Evidence Appraisal Worksheets
PICO Worksheet
Your Name:
Date:
Your Instructor’s Name:
 
Purpose: To identify a problem or concern that nursing can change and develop a PICO question to guide the change project.
Directions: Use the form below to complete the PICO assignment in Milestone #1. This includes filling in the table with information about your research question and your PICO elements.
Step 1: Identify the problem. What have you noticed in your work or school environment that isn’t achieving the desired patient or learning outcomes? What needs to change in nursing, what can you change with the support of evidence in the literature? Briefly describe the problem or practice issue that you want to research. What is your practice area; clinical, education, or administration?
Step 2: How was the practice issues identified? How did you come to know this was a problem in your clinical practice? Review the listed concerns and check all that apply.
Step 3: What is the scope of the problem? Does this problem affect an individual, population, or an entire institution?
Step 4: Select the key PICO terms for searching the evidence. Clearly define your PICO question. List each element P (problem, population, or problem), I (intervention), C (Comparison with other treatment/current practice), and O (Desired outcome). Is the potential solution something for which you (as nurse or student) can find a solution through evidence research? Look in your book for guidelines to developing your PICO question.
Step 5: What evidence must be gathered? Everyone should have a literature search. However, what other sources of reliable information will be helpful for your particular question?
Step 6: State the search question in narrow, manageable terms. What terms will you use in order to make sure that your search is wide enough to obtain required information but narrow enough to keep it focused? How will you narrow your search if needed?
 
 

PICO Worksheet
What is the practice issue/problem? 
What is the practice area?___ Clinical
___ Education
___ Administration
___ Other
How was the practice issue identified? (check all that apply)___ Safety/risk management concerns
___ Unsatisfactory patient outcomes
___ Wide variations in practice
___ Significant financial concerns
___ Difference between hospital and community practice
___ Clinical practice issue is a concern
___ Procedure or process is a time waster
___ Clinical practice issue has no scientific base
___ Other
What is the scope of the problem?___ Individual
___ Population
___ Institution/system
What is the PICO question?___ P– (Patient, population, or problem):
___ I– (Intervention):
___ C– (Comparison with other treatment/current practice):
___ O– (Desired outcome):
What evidence must be gathered? (check all that apply)
___  Literature search___ Guidelines
___  Expert Opinion
___  Patient Preferences
___  Clinical Expertise___  Financial Analysis
___  Standards (Regulatory, professional, community)
___ Other
State the search question in narrow, manageable terms: 

Evidence Appraisal Worksheet
Your Name:
Date:
Your Instructor’s Name:
 
Purpose: To find evidence to support an intervention that will change the outcomes.
Directions: Type your search question below. Find AT LEAST FOUR sources to support the need for change and the potential intervention you have selected to solve the problem. At least three of your sources must be peer-reviewed articles. The forth source could be another peer-reviewed article or a reliable, credible source. Look in your text for ideas of other sources that can be used. Using the table below, insert and describe your four chosen resources.
Step 1: APA Reference for the article. You will need to list the reference for the source in APA format. Be careful when using built-in APA formats and library citations. They may not be in APA format. Refer to Chapter 7 of your APA manual.
Step 2: Type of Source. If your source is a research article, you will need to ensure that it is a peer review article. You need at least three peer-reviewed articles for your project. If your article is a non–research source, then you will need to list what type of source it is; systematic review, clinical practice guidelines, organizational experience, or individual expert opinion/case study/literature review. You may only use ONE non-research source.
Step 3: Strength of Research. Refer to page 238-240 for research evidence and page 242-244 for non-research evidence. While you do not need to assign a level for each study, you will assign a quality of evidence (high, good, or low/major flaw) and should discuss the study using some of the elements that are discussed in the appraisal forms. For example, Research evidence: was the sample size adequate? Was there a controlled group? Was it a randomized study? Were results clearly stated? Was the conclusion based on the results? Were study limitations discussed? Not all of these elements need to be discussed, but you should discuss this information to determine if the strength of the evidence is HIGH, GOOD, or LOW/MAJOR FLAW.
Step 4: Brief Description of the Research. In this section, you will summarize the source in your own words. How does this information apply to your project? What are the results of the source? What are their recommendations?
 
 

Evidence Appraisal Worksheet
PICO Question: 
APA Reference for ArticleGive the APA-formatted reference for the article. Type of Source*Research: Peer-reviewed article
*Non-research systematic review, clinical practice guidelines, organizational experience, or expert opinion/case study/literature review
Strength of ResearchDiscuss the strength of the sources.
Report if evidence is High, Good, or Low/Major Flaw. Use the tools on page 238-244 of your text and discuss the reasons why you have assigned a particular level of quality.
Brief Description of ResearchAddress the questions.
*How does the information in the article apply to the project problem or proposed intervention?
*Summarize in your own words.
* Include results of the study and how these results are applicable to your project.
* What is the recommendation of the source for clinical practice?
1
2
3
4

 
Capstone Project Milestone #1:
PICO and Evidence Appraisal Guidelines
Purpose
Clear identification of the problem or opportunity is the first step in evidence-based nursing. This first milestone offers two tools to assist in the identification and gathering of evidence to link the problem, proposed intervention, and desired outcomes. Completion of the milestone will include identification of the problem or concern using the PICO format and an evidence appraisal to find evidence to support an intervention that will change the outcomes.
Course Outcomes
This assignment enables the student to meet the following Course Outcomes.
CO4: Develops and outlines a scientific, systematic decision-making process to integrate critical thinking with clinical judgment to assure safe and effective outcomes. (PO #4)
CO8: Selects evidence for best practice when planning professional nursing care for individuals, families, aggregates, and communities. (PO #8)
Due Date
Milestone #1 consists of the completion of one worksheet that contains two parts (i.e., the PICO worksheet and the evidence appraisal worksheet). Submit the file with the two worksheets completed to the Dropbox by Sunday, 11:59 p.m. MT at the end of Week 2.
Points
Milestone #1 is worth 175 points (75 points for the PICO worksheet and 100 points for the evidence appraisal worksheet).
Directions

  1. Read this document including the grading rubrics below.
  2. Download the PICO/Evidence Appraisal worksheets form from Doc Sharing. Consider what is the nursing problem or issue that you have uncovered. Make sure it is related to nursing, i.e., one that a nurse can solve independently. Do not select a medical problem that is dependent upon a medical professional to resolve. Completion of PICO worksheet will offer a tool for your literature search.
  3. For the evidence appraisal worksheet, find AT LEAST FOUR sources to support the need for change and the potential intervention you have selected to solve the problem. Three of these sources must be peer-reviewed articles while one can be a reliable professional source.
  4. Submit the completed PICO/Evidence Appraisal worksheet to the Week 2 Dropbox.

WHAT ARE THE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE PATIENT OR POPULATION?

Professional Nursing Practice
NUR 4827
Benjamin Leon School of Nursing
Miami Dade College
BSN Program
Scholarly Paper and Presentation Guidelines and Rubric
 
 
The PICO concept will be established in the scholarly paper and presentation project to reflect a quality improvement perspective that you will present as a scholarly paper then converted to a group presentation.

                  PICO Format for Group Project Presentation

  • Patient, Population or Problem
    • What are the characteristics of the patient or population?
    • What is the condition or disease you are interested in?
  • Intervention or exposure
    • What do you want to do with this patient (e.g. treat, diagnose, observe)?
  • Comparison
    • What is the alternative to the intervention (e.g. placebo, different drug, surgery)?
  • Outcome
    • What are the relevant outcomes (e.g. morbidity, death, complications)?

 
The scholarly paper and presentation will have references from the various levels of evidence as described in the pyramid of empirical evidence presented by your professor as posted in ANGEL
 
                             Scholarly Paper & Presentation Content Sequence to Follow
 
                                 Scholarly Paper Sequence: Must be written in APA Format
 
                                 Paper will include the following in Sub-Headings:
 
 

  • Introduction (10%): The Relevance of the Problem to Healthcare Delivery System when promoting Quality and Safety

Problem Statement (15%): Why is it Personal Area of Interest for Professional Nursing Care?
Ex: Core Measures, National Patient Safety Goals, Negative Clinical Indicators, Unit Based Problems.
What type of data is being presented to reflect the problem in numbers for the past three months? Graphs, tables, fiscal report in numbers.
Goal(s) and Objectives of the Quality Improvement Project (25%): The team will produce data that reflect improvement with reasonable interventions addressing the improved clinical indicators to appropriate benchmark number acceptable to regulatory practice.

  • Action Plan (25%): PICO Format Problem, Intervention, Comparison and Outcome

Level Three Evaluation: Education, Validation and Simulation

  • Conclusion (15%): What was the outcome?  Did the problem resolve and or did the Team’s project improve the situation? What would be the future implications for Nursing Practice and Healthcare Delivery
  • References (10%): From various levels of evidence: SEE PYRAMID BELOW

 
THE TOPIC TO WRITE SCHOLARLY PAPER IS” Hospital acquired infections and poor patient outcomes”
Below is the format for the scholarly to be accepted by the professor
Homework for a leadership class in bachelor nursing program.
Present a business proposal to a CEO to show him/her how that proposal will eliminate infections acquired from Foley catheter and central line in this hospital. In order to get hired, I have to come up with new plans that will show the CEO that my proposal is successful by comparing my new graphs with a very low percentage or zero infection from Foley catheter and central line. Which will show my plan is better than the previous one that was in place. I have to provide graphs to compare my proposal success of the new plans vs the old plan graph that was in place, after 6 months of trial. This success would get me hired.
The topic is listed as follows: “ Eliminate hospital acquired Foley catheter and central line infection and poor patient outcomes” the homework is required 8 pages, an abstract, an introduction, benchmark of PICO as above APA style, using information from systematic reviews and peer reviews no later than 5 years old with 6 references in a separate page

One of the key roles of the master’s-prepared nurse is to lead practice change across the full spectrum of healthcare settings.

Introduction:
One of the key roles of the master’s-prepared nurse is to lead practice change across the full spectrum of healthcare settings. Master’s-prepared nurses must be able to translate the existing body of knowledge around a phenomenon of interest (accessible through published research studies) to inform decision making related to nursing practice.
Requirements:
A. Identify a current nursing practice within your healthcare setting that requires change. 1. Describe the current nursing practice. 2. Discuss why the current nursing practice needs to be changed.
B. Identify the key stakeholders within your healthcare setting who are part of the current nursing practice. 1. Describe the role each identified key stakeholder will play to support the proposed practice change.
C. Create an evidence critique table (see “Sample Evidence Critique Table”). 1. Identify five sources from scholarly peer-reviewed journals, which adhere to the following standards: a. Each source must be published within the past five years. b. Each source must relate to the change identified in part A. c. Each source must be listed in the table using APA format. 2. Identify the evidence strength of each chosen source, using the Strength of Evidence Table in the study plan. 3. Identify the evidence hierarchy of each chosen source, using the Evidence Hierarchy Table in the study plan.
D. Develop an evidence summary based on the findings from part C that includes each of the five sources used (suggested length of 1–2 pages for all sources).
E. Recommend a specific best practice based on the evidence summary developed in part D.
F. Identify a practice change model that is appropriate to apply to the proposed practice change. 1. Justify why you chose the practice change model. 2. Explain how to apply the identified model to guide the implementation of the proposed practice change.
G. Discuss possible barriers to successful implementation of the proposed practice change.
H. Discuss any possible ethical implications that may arise while planning or implementing the proposed practice change.
I. When you use sources, include all in-text citations and references in APA format.
Note: For definitions of terms commonly used in the rubric, see the Rubric Terms web link included in the Evaluation Procedures section.
Note: When using sources to support ideas and elements in an assessment, the submission MUST include APA formatted in-text citations with a corresponding reference list for any direct quotes or paraphrasing. It is not necessary to list sources that were consulted if they have not been quoted or paraphrased in the text of the assessment.
Note: No more than a combined total of 30% of a submission can be directly quoted or closely paraphrased from outside sources, even if cited correctly. For tips on using APA style, please refer to the APA Handout web link included in the APA Guidelines section.
File Attachments: 1. Translational Research Sample Evidence Critique Table link opens in new window
Sample Evidence Critique Table:

Full APA citation for at least 5 sources Evidence Strength (1-7) and Evidence Hierarchy
  1. Tricco, A. C., Cogo, E., Holroyd-Leduc, J., et al. (2013). Efficacy of falls prevention interventions: Protocol for a systemic review and network meta-analysis. Systematic Reviews, 2, 38.  doi: 10.1186/2046-4053-2-38
1 and Systematic review
2.
3.
4.
5.

Note:  Evidence Strength will range from level 7 (lowest) to level 1 (highest).  Evidence Hierarchy will reflect the research methodology (Expert Opinion [lowest] to Meta-Analysis [highest]).

consider that you are the assistant manager of operations for the Smith Home Health Care Services. Part of your job is to do impromptu visits where internal audits are completed as a measure to monitor the home health nurses and aides for the company.

These responses are based on these set of questions and each response must be answered in 100 or more words in APA format.
 
Falsification of records and billing are serious offenses and must be treated as such. As a health administrator, you will be called upon to monitor staff to be sure that records and billing are accurate.
In this scenario, consider that you are the assistant manager of operations for the Smith Home Health Care Services. Part of your job is to do impromptu visits where internal audits are completed as a measure to monitor the home health nurses and aides for the company.
You have been observing Barbara Smithers, who has been a home health aide since the company was established in 1995. You notice, before one of your monitoring visits, that Barbara’s billing totals seem higher than the average worker. When you observe her home services and compare them to the services rendered, there is a discrepancy. Going back in her service records, this has been a pattern for at least 4 years. You report this to your supervisor, Ron James. Mr. James meets with Barbara, who finally admits that she has been “padding” the billing for at least 10 years, at the demand of nursing supervisor, Donna Strickland. Mr. James asks you to sit in on a conference with Ms. Strickland and Ms. Smithers and contribute to questioning them and helping make a final decision.

  • If accusations turn out to be true, what would be your recommendation in this case be to the Mr. James? What records do you need to review before the conference? Be sure to cite standards from the False Claims Act.
  • How did the Service fail in its responsibility in monitoring Barbara? Should the facility also be held responsible?
  • Could the Service have avoided this situation? Does 4 years of potential fraudulent billing seem a reasonable time period for no one to notice?
  • What are the consequences of this behavior? Is there a criminal case here? What about civil liability? Are there any non-monetary consequences this Service should now be worried about?

First response:
I am the assistant manager of operations for the Smith Home Health Care Services. I have been observing Barbara, who has been a home health aide since the company was established in 1995. I have noticed, before one of my monitoring visits, that Barbara’s billing totals sum higher the average worker. When I observed her home services and compare them to the services rendered, there was a discrepancy. Looking back in her service records, this has been a pattern for at least 4 years. I reported this to my supervisor, Ron James. Mr. James meets with Barbara, who finally admits that she has been “padding” the billing for at least 10 years, at the demand of nursing supervisor, Donna Strickland. Mr. James asks me to sit in on a conference with Ms. Strickland and Ms. Smithers and contribute to questioning them and helping make a final decision.
If the accusations turn out to be true, what would be my recommendations in this case in reference to Mr. James? What records do you need to review before the conference? When Mr. James questions Barbara, Barbara admits she has been “padding” the billing for at least 10 years, so at this point we can say that the accusation is true and that the act was willing. My recommendations to Mr. James would be to start a plan of correction and audit all of the billing claims in the organization for accuracy and set a monitoring system to make sure that the fraudulent behavior does not happen again. In addition, termination of employee and taking out criminal charges. Before the conference a thorough investigation of the claims records would need to be reviewed from the past 10 years. Barbara has now subjected the organization and herself to the False Claims Act which states:

  • “Knowingly presents, or causes to be presented, to an officer or employee of the United States a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval”;
  • “Knowingly makes, uses, or causes to be made or used, a false record or statement to get a false or fraudulent claim paid or approved by the Government”;
  • “Conspires to defraud the Government by getting a false or fraudulent claim allowed or paid (Showalter, 2012, p. 437).

How did the service fail in its responsibility in monitoring Barbara? Should the facility be held responsible? Well, in the scenario it states that Barbara has had a pattern for at least 4 years and Barbara states she has been “padding” for the past 10 years. So, this just tell us that there was indeed a system failure and that claim records were not being monitored on a consistent basis to assure accuracy? Yes, the facility should be held responsible. It is the responsibility of the healthcare administrator to make sure that mechanisms such as corporate compliance programs put in place to verify accuracy of their organization’s claims. According to Showalter (2012), this standard requires healthcare providers, and their tip management and governing board members, to have mechanisms in place to verify the accuracy of their organization’s claims. When a healthcare provider fail in its responsibility in monitoring its claims the organization will come into the subjection of the False Claims Act.
 
Could the service have avoided this situation? Does 4 years of potential fraudulent billing seem a reasonable time period for no one to notice? Yes this situation could have been avoided. This was definitely a system breakdown. It is the responsibility of the healthcare administrator to make sure that mechanisms such as corporate compliance programs put in place to verify accuracy of their organization’s claims. No, 4 years of potential fraudulent billing does not seem to be a reasonable time period for no one to notice. According to Showalter (2012), this standard requires healthcare providers, and their top management and governing board members, to have mechanisms in place to verify the accuracy of their organization’s claims.
What are the consequences of the behavior?

  • False Claims Act (FCA) violations range from $5,500 to $11,000 per claim
  • Civil penalties
  • Criminal convictions
  • Loss of participation in Medicare and Medicaid

The threat and the potential for criminal convictions and massive fines have been the major forces motivating healthcare organizations to adopt corporate compliance programs (Showalter, 2012, p. 439).
Is there a criminal case here? What about civil liability? Are there any non-monetary consequences this Service should now be worried about? Yes, there is a criminal case and a civil liability. Yes, there are non-monetary consequences this Service should now be worried. One non-monetary consequence the Service should be worried about is their reputation that is now under scrutiny and at stake in the community.
 
Reference:
Showalter, J. S. (2012). The Law of Healthcare Administration. (6th ed.). Chicago, IL: Health Administration Press.
Second response:
Falsification of records and billing are serious offenses under the law. For these reason, as a health administrator, I will supervise and monitor staff to make sure that each employee is following procedure; but in this case I will implement an emergency meeting with the upper level executive CEO, all supervisor/ managers, a lawyer/consultant, financial management coordinator, Donna S. Ms. Strickland, Ms. Smithers, Mr. James, and Barbara, who admits that she has been padding the billing for ten years. In the meeting I will discuss and review policies, evaluations, supervision notes, trainings, credentials/education, claims, financial statements/ records, and be able to clarify the protocols/professional ethic.  After everything is review I will pursue with the federal law.  As a health administrator I will never wait to report a fraud, because then I will be involve in this fraudulent conduct. According with Showalter, (2012),  “Any person who knowingly files a statement of claim containing any misrepresentation or any false, incomplete or misleading information may be guilty of a criminal act punishable under law and may be subject to civil penalties”(p. 441).   Subsequently, staff is expected to follow healthcare organization financial rules and information management policies regarding medical records which each employee is responsible for their job. Showalter report that, “Federal law makes filing false claims a criminal offense. An organization may be fined $500,000 or twice the amount of the false claims whichever is greater. An individual may be fined the greater of $250,000 or twice the amount of the false claim and may be five years of prison” (John R. Showarlter, 2012, p. 441)
Anti-Fraud campaign article by Lisa explain explained that, “Frauds costs the US. Healthcare system some $65 billion a year from Medicare alone, and the affordable Care Act (ACA) give the government greater authority to identify and prosecute fraud and abuse.  Especially considering the most recent federal task force bust that tallied $430 million in false billing claim and levied charges against 100 individuals including physicians” (Zamosky, 2012).  As a consequence, ACE create a new strategy plan, implementing educational training for staff, strategies to resolve a billing errors, building a compliance plan, conduct your own audits, increase new technology, controlling the HER, and dealing with an audit.
In conclusion, I believe that staff must be educated, to be honest, make sure they understand policies, financial statements, and follows the law. Managers and supervisor must to be aware of any issues, implementing schedules for supervision, meetings, measure performance evaluation/ feedbacks, provide training according with the organization goals, hire lawyer or consultant, an accountant, to review audits/financial records, and policies. As a result, to avoid any other fraud.
Reference
John R. Showarlter, J. M. (2012). The law of Healthcare Administration . Washington DC.
Zamosky, L. (2012, December). Anti-Faud campaing could trigger wave of audits, experts warn. Retrieved from http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/oped/bs-ed-obamacare-20131021-story.html.