Susan Lyons woke up on a Saturday morning with all the symptoms of strep throat, but her doctor’s office was closed for the weekend. Jeremy Brown struggled to get through his workday because of a sinus infection, but he didn’t have time on his lunch break to drive across town to see his family physician.

Susan Lyons woke up on a Saturday morning with all the symptoms of strep throat, but her doctor’s office was closed for the weekend. Jeremy Brown struggled to get through his workday because of a sinus infection, but he didn’t have time on his lunch break to drive across town to see his family physician.  Kumar went to his doctor for a flu shot but was turned away because they had already run out of the vaccine. In the end, all three turned to  for treatment instead. MinuteClinic healthcare centers are open seven days a week with later hours than traditional doctors have. They don’t require appointments and can provide patients with a diagnosis and prescription within 15-45 minutes, tops. The fact that they are located in convenient retail settings, usually attached to a CVS drugstore where the prescription can be filled in one stop, adds to their growing appeal. “It was such a pleasant experience,”  Kumar says after paying $30 for a flu shot at , “that I figured that I would be happy to go back there for minor ailments and avoid the long waits at my doctor’s office.” , which opened its first location in 2000, was the pioneer of in-store clinics and an innovator in what industry analysts call the “ of healthcare.” Considering the growing need for cheaper, more accessible healthcare, it’s no surprise that the company is expanding so quickly. CVS acquired  in July 2006 and announced plans to grow from 128 locations to nearly 500 by early 2008. Staffed by nurse practitioners and physician assistants who specialize in family healthcare,  provides basic medical services for common ailments such as ear infections and strep throat.  locations also offer vaccines and physicals. An electronic medical records system streamlines the process for each patient by generating educational materials, invoices, and prescriptions at the end of the visit. Electronic records also make it possible to instantly transfer information to the patients’ primary physicians.  prices range from about $50-$80, making a visit about half as expensive as one to a doctor’s office.  CEO Michael C. Howe says, “MinuteClinic is an example of how creativity and innovation can be brought to our struggling healthcare system to affect change and make basic care more accessible and affordable for today’s consumer.” The American Medical Association (AMA) has expressed reservations, however. Board member Dr. Rebecca  explains, “The AMA is concerned about patients who would seek care in a freestanding clinic and have a more serious disease that would not be initially diagnosed or diagnosed quickly.” Howe insists they are not trying to replace the traditional family physician, however; they simply want to offer a convenient, low-cost alternative for patients with minor illnesses. Patients exhibiting symptoms outside of the clinic’s scope of services or showing signs of a chronic condition are referred elsewhere.  ability to handle widespread health emergencies within a community was tested when Minnesota was hit with a string of flu-related deaths in 2007. As a record number of residents sought vaccinations,  quickly put a plan in place to address the crisis and meet the unexpected demand. Instead of boosting staff at all facilities in the Minneapolis area, the company chose a hub-and-spoke approach for better inventory control, offering the shots in only eight  locations. They hired supplemental nursing staff for those clinics and administered up to 300 shots a day in each. The lines became so long that they created children’s areas to make the wait easier for families, adding televisions, videos, and coloring books to keep little ones entertained and fostering what Donna Haugland of  describes as “a community-building environment.” CEO Howe praised the good work they did during the flu crisis: “It is amazing what practitioners can do in the right environment and given the chance.” Patients agree. The response to the clinics has been overwhelmingly positive. A 2006 Harris Interactive poll reported that 92% of the people who visited a retail clinic were satisfied with its convenience, 89% were satisfied with the quality of care they received, and 80% were satisfied with the cost. Even the AMA is advising traditional physicians to consider changing their practices to better compete with retail clinics by extending office hours, offering same-day appointments, or even doing away with appointments altogether. AMA Board member  admits, “With their quick and easy access and low prices, the store-based clinics are obviously meeting a need.”25 Questions 1. Describe how  puts the following promotion strategies to work for them: stressing tangible cues, using personal information sources, creating a strong organizational image, and engaging in post-purchase communication. What else could they try? 2. Are  services customized or standardized for patients? Do they incorporate any elements of mass customization? 3. In what way did MinuteClinic demonstrate reliability and responsiveness during the flu outbreak in Minnesota? How did it impress customers with tangible physical evidence that the clinics cared about them? 4. How important has  place (distribution) strategy been to the company’s success? Which elements does  focus on with its marketing mix? Why?

Review the case of Paradise Hills Medical Center

Review the case of Paradise Hills Medical Center, below. The CEO
has asked you for a recommendation. What will you tell him?
PARADISE HILLS Medical Center is a 500-bed teaching hospital in
a major metropolitan area of the South. It is known throughout a
tri-state area for its comprehensive oncology program and serves as
a regional referral center for thousands of patients suffering from
various forms of malignant disease.
Paradise Hills is affiliated with a major university and has
residency programs in internal medicine, surgery, pediatrics,
obstetrics/gynecology, psychiatry, radiology, and pathology, all
fully accredited by the Accrediting Commission for Graduate Medical
Education. In addition, Paradise Hills also has an oncology an
oncology fellowship program, a university-affiliated nursing
program, as well as training programs for radiology technicians and
medical technologists. All of these teaching programs are highly
regarded and attract students from across the nation.
Paradise Hills enjoys an enviable reputation throughout the
area. It is known for its high-quality care, its state-of-the-art
technology, and its competent, caring staff. While Paradise Hills
is located within a highly competitive healthcare community, it
boasts a strong market share for its service area. Indeed, its
oncology program enjoys a 75 percent market share and its patients
provide significant referrals to the surgery, pediatrics, and
radiology programs as well.
Paradise Hills is a financially strong institution with equally
strong leadership. Its past successes, in large part, can be
attributed to its aggressive, visionary CEO and his exceptionally
competent management staff.
But all is not as well as it seems to be at Paradise Hills.
While the oncology program still enjoys a healthy market share, it
has been slowly but steadily declining from its peak of 82 percent
two years ago. In addition, the program’s medical staff are aging
and some of its highest admitting physicians are contemplating
retirement. The oncology fellowship program was established a few
years ago in anticipation of this, but unfortunately, thus far the
graduates of this program have not elected to stay in the
community. Of most concern to the CEO and his staff is the fact
that the hospital’s major competitor has recently recruited a
highly credentialed oncology medical group practice from the
Northeast and has committed enormous resources to strengthening its
own struggling oncology program.
Last week the board of trustees for Paradise Hills had its
monthly meeting with a fairly routine agenda. However, during
review of a standard quality assurance report, one of the trustees
asked for clarification of a portion of the report indicating that
22 oncology patients had received radiation therapy dosages in
excess of what had been prescribed for them. The board was informed
that the errors had occurred due to a flaw in the calibration of
the equipment. The board was also informed that the medical
physicist responsible for the errors had been asked to resign his
position. The question was then asked if the patients who were
recipients of the excessive radiation had been told of the error.
The CEO responded that it was the responsibility of the medical
staff to address this issue and it was their decision that the
patients not be informed of the errors. The board did not concur
that the responsibility for informing the patients of the errors
rested solely with the medical staff and requested that the
administrative staff review the hospital’s ethical responsibility
to these patients, as well as its liability related to this
incident, and report back to the board within two weeks.
The CEO and his management staff responsible for the radiology
department and the oncology program met with the medical staff
department chairmen for internal medicine and radiology, the
program medical directors for oncology and radiation therapy, and
the attending oncologists. The CEO reported on the board discussion
related to the incident and the board’s request for a review of the
actions taken, specifically the decision to not inform the affected
patients.
The physicians as a whole agreed that the adverse effects of the
accidental radiation overdose on the patients were unknown.
Therefore, they argued the patients should not be told of the
incident. These are cancer patients and they don’t want or need any
more bad news, the oncologists argued. “Let’s face it, these
patients are terminal.” “Informing the patients of this error will
only confuse them and destroy their faith and trust in their
physicians and in the hospital,” they added. Furthermore, they
claimed, informing the patients of the errors may unnecessarily
frighten them to the extent that they may refuse further treatment
and that would be even more detrimental to them. Besides, argued
the physicians, advising the patients of potential ill effects just
might induce these symptoms through suggestion or excessive worry.
Every procedure has its risks, insisted the chairman for radiology,
and these patients signed an informed consent.
Physicians know what is best for their patients, the attending
oncologists maintained, and they will monitor these patients for
any ill effects. The department chairman for internal medicine
volunteered that, in his opinion, this incident is clearly a
patient-physician relationship responsibility and not the business
of the hospital. Besides, added the chairman of radiology,
informing the patients would “just be asking for malpractice
litigation.”
The medical director for the oncology program then suggested
that the board of trustees and the management staff “think long and
hard” about the public relations effect of this incident on the
oncology program. “Do you really think patients will want to come
to Paradise Hills if they think we’re incompetent?”, he asked.
The CEO conceded that he supported the position of the medical
staff in this matter and he, too, was especially concerned about
preserving the image of the oncology program, but “his hands were
tied” since the board clearly considered this an ethical issue and
one that would be referred to the hospital’s ethics committee for
its opinion.
The physicians noted that if indeed it was the subsequent
recommendation of the ethics committee that these patients be
informed, then realistically, that responsibility would rest with
the patient’s primary care physician and not with any of them.

Business people enhance their written communications by using appropriate methods of organization.

Organization methods
Business people enhance their written communications by using
appropriate methods of organization. Determine the
best method for each of the topics below.
METHODS OF ORGANIZATION
sequential
division and classification
general to specific
chronological
decreasing order of importance
specific to general
spatial
increasing order of importance
comparison
SELECT FIVE (5):
TOPIC:
STUDENT RESPONSE:
Best organizational method
Announcing the winners of an election
Explaining different NYC subway lines
Describing the layout of your workspace
Determining the best school to attend
Instructions on how to cook a vegetable omelet
Supporting an argument against smoking
Take one of these topics and create an outline using that
organization method.
EXAMPLE:
Describing college schools and departments
METHOD:
Division and Classification
OUTLINE:
School of Arts and Humanities
Academic Departments: African and African American Studies; Art;
English; History; Journalism, Communication, and Theatre; Languages
and Literatures; Latin American, Latino, and Puerto Rican Studies;
Music; and Philosophy.
School of Natural and Social Sciences
Academic Departments: Anthropology, Biological Sciences,
Chemistry, Earth, Environmental, & Geospatial Sciences,
Economics & Business, Mathematics & Computer Science,
Physics & Astronomy, Political Science, Psychology,
Sociology
School of Health Sciences, Human Services and Nursing
Academic Departments: Health Sciences; Social Work; Nursing; and
Speech, Language and Hearing Sciences.
TOPIC:
METHOD:
OUTLINE:

One of the most consistent changes in the structure of work over the past few decades has been a shift from a manufacturing economy to a service economy. More workers are now engaged in jobs that include providing care and assistance

Learning Goals
One of the most consistent changes in the structure of work over
the past few decades has been a shift from a manufacturing economy
to a service economy. More workers are now engaged in jobs that
include providing care and assistance, especially in education and
medicine. This work is satisfying for some people, but it can also
be highly stressful. In the following sce- nario, consider how a
company in the nursing care industry is responding to the
challenges of the new environment.
Major Topic Areas
? Stress
? Organizational change
? Emotions
? Leadership
The Scenario
Parkway Nursing Care is an organization facing a mas- sive
change. The company was founded in 1972 with just two nursing homes
in Phoenix, Arizona. The com- pany was very successful, and
throughout the 1980s it continued to turn a consistent profit while
slowly ac- quiring or building 30 more units. This low-profile ap-
proach changed forever in 1993 when venture capitalist Robert Quine
decided to make a major investment in expanding Parkway in return
for a portion of its profits over the coming years. The number of
nursing homes exploded, and Parkway was operating 180 homes by the
year 2000.
The company now has 220 facilities in the south- western United
States, with an average of 115 beds per facility and a total of
nearly 30,000 employees. In ad- dition to health care facilities,
it also provides skilled in-home nursing care. Parkway is seen as
one of the best care facilities in the region, and it has won
numerous awards for its achievements in the field.
As members of the Baby Boom generation become senior citizens,
the need for skilled care will only in- crease. Parkway wants to
make sure it is in a good position to meet this growing need. This
means the company must continue expanding rapidly.
The Stress of Caring
The pressure for growth is one significant challenge, but it’s
not the only one. The nursing home industry has come under
increasing government scrutiny following investigations that turned
up widespread patient abuse and billing fraud. Parkway has always
had outstanding patient care, and no substantiated claim of abuse
or ne- glect in any of its homes has ever been made, but the need
for increased documentation will still affect the company. As the
federal government tries to trim Medi- care expenses, Parkway may
face a reduction in funding.
The Problem
As growth has continued, Parkway has remained com- mitted to
providing dignity and health to all residents in its facilities.
The board of directors wants to see re- newed commitment to the
firm’s mission and core values, not a diffusion of its culture. Its
members are worried there might be problems to address. Interviews
with employees suggest there’s plenty to worry about.
Shift leader Maxine Vernon has been with Parkway for 15 years.
“Now that the government keeps a closer eye on our staffing levels,
I’ve seen management do what it can to keep positions filled, and I
don’t always agree with who is hired. Some of the basic job skills
can be taught, sure, but how to care for our patients—a
lot of these new kids just don’t pick up on that.”
“The problem isn’t with staff—it’s with Parkway’s fo- cus on
filling the beds,” says nurse’s aide Bobby Reed. “When I started
here, Parkway’s reputation was still about the service. Now it’s
about numbers. No one is in- tentionally negligent—there just are
too many patients to see.”
A recent college graduate with a B.A. in psychol- ogy, Dalton
Manetti is more stressed than he expected he would be. “These
aren’t the sweet grannies you see in the movies. Our patients are
demanding. They complain about everything, even about being called
patients, probably because most of them think they shouldn’t be
here in the first place. A lot of times, their gripes amount to
nothing, but we have to log them in anyway.”
Carmen Frank has been with Parkway almost a year and is already
considering finding a new job. “I knew there were going to be
physical parts to this job, and I thought I’d be able to handle
that. It’s not like I was looking for a desk job, you know? I go
home after every
shift with aches all over—my back, my arms, my legs. I’ve never
had to take so much time off from a job be- cause I hurt. And then
when I come back, I feel like the rest of the staff thinks I’m
weak.”
“I started working here right out of high school be- cause it
was the best-paid of the jobs I could get,” says Niecey Wilson. “I
had no idea what I was getting myself into. Now I really like my
job. Next year I’m going to start taking some night classes so I
can move into an- other position. But some of the staff just think
of this as any other job. They don’t see the patients as people,
more like inventory. If they want to work with inven- tory, they
should get a job in retail.”
Last month, the company’s human resources de- partment pulled
the following information from its records at the request of the
board of directors. The numbers provide some quantitative support
for the concerns voiced by staff.
Injuries to staff occur mostly because of back strain from
lifting patients. Patient incidents reflect injuries due to slips,
falls, medication errors, or other accidents. Certified absences
are days off from work due to medi- cally verified illnesses or
injuries. Other absences are days missed that are not due to
injuries or illnesses; these are excused absences (unexcused
absences are grounds for immediate firing).
Using Organizational Development to Combat Stress and
Improve Performance
The company wants to use such organizational devel- opment
methods as appreciative inquiry (AI) to cre- ate change and
reenergize its sense of mission. As the
chapter on organizational change explains, AI proce- dures
systematically collect employee input and then use this information
to create a change message every- one can support. The human
resources department conducted focus groups, asking employees to
describe some of their concerns and suggestions for the future. The
focus groups highlighted a number of suggestions, although they
don’t all suggest movement in the same direction.
Many suggestions concerned schedule flexibility. One
representative comment was this: “Most of the stress on this job
comes because we can’t take time off when we need it. The LPNs
[licensed practical nurses, who do much of the care] and orderlies
can’t take time off when they need to, but a lot of them are single
parents or primary caregivers for their own children. When they
have to leave for child care responsibilities, the work suffers and
there’s no contingency plan to help smooth things over. Then
everyone who is left has to work extra hard. The person who takes
time off feels guilty, and there can be fights over taking time
off. If we had some way of covering these emergency absences, we’d
all be a lot happier, and I think the care would be a lot
better.”
Other suggestions proposed a better method for communicating
information across shifts. Most of the documentation for shift work
is done in large spiral notebooks. When a new shift begins, staff
members say they don’t have much time to check on what happened in
the previous shift. Some younger caregivers would like to have a
method that lets them document patient outcomes electronically
because they type faster than they can write. The older caregivers
are more commit- ted to the paper-based process, in part because
they think switching systems would require a lot of work.
(Government regulations on health care reporting re- quire that any
documentation be made in a form that cannot be altered after the
fact, to prevent covering up
abuse, so specialized software systems must be used for
electronic documentation.) Finally, the nursing care staff believes
its perspec- tives on patient care are seldom given an appropriate
hearing. “We’re the ones who are with the patients most of the
time, but when it comes to doing this the right way, our point of
view gets lost. We really could save a lot of money by eliminating
some of these un- necessary routines and programs, but it’s
something management always just says it will consider.” Staff
members seem to want some way to provide sugges- tions for
improvement, but it isn’t clear what method they would prefer.
Injuries per Staff Member
Incidents per Patient
Certified Absences per Staff
Other Absence per Staff
Turnover Rate
2000
21,200
3.32
4.98
4.55
3.14
0.31
2001
22,300
3.97
5.37
5.09
3.31
0.29
2002
22,600
4.87
5.92
4.71
3.47
0.28
2003
23,100
4.10
6.36
5.11
3.61
0.35
2004
23,300
4.21
6.87
5.66
4.03
0.31
2005
23,450
5.03
7.36
5.33
3.45
0.28
2006
23,600
5.84
7.88
5.28
4.24
0.36
2007
24,500
5.62
8.35
5.86
4.06
0.33
2008
24,100
7.12
8.84
5.63
3.89
0.35
2009
25,300
6.95
9.34
6.11
4.28
0.35
Your Assignment
Parkway has taken some initial steps toward a new direc- tion,
but clearly it has a lot of work left to do. You’ve been brought in
as a change management consultant to help the company change its
culture and respond to the stress that employees experience.
Remember to create your report as if for the leadership of a major
corporation.
When you write your recommendations, make sure you touch on the
following points:
1. What do the data on employee injuries,
incidents, absences, and turnover suggest to you? Is there rea- son
for concern about the company’s direction?
2. The company is going to be making some
signifi- cant changes based on the AI process, and most change
efforts are associated with resistance. What are the most common
forms of resistance, and which would you expect to see at
Parkway?
3. Given the board of directors’ desire to
reenergize the workforce, what advice would you provide for
creating a leadership strategy? What leader behav- iors should
nursing home directors and nurse su- pervisors demonstrate?
4. What are the major sources of job stress at
Parkway? What does the research on employee stress suggest you
should do to help minimize the experience of psychological strain
for employees? Create a plan for how to reduce stress among
employees.
5. Based on the information collected in the
focus groups, design a survey to hand out to employees. What sort
of data should the survey gather? What types of data analysis
methods would you like to em- ploy for these data?