Program Evaluation as a Key Tool in Health and Human Services 

Program Evaluation as a Key Tool in Health and Human Services
Evidence-based practice utilizes a variety of research methods  to gather evidence as to the efficacy of a program’s effectiveness, or  cost effectiveness. According to your text, “Sound research and its  applications, although not guarantees of perfect policies and programs,  are extremely useful tools in developing sound social policies and  programs” (p. 281). Additionally, we read that evaluation research is  different from “basic” research in that evaluation research is based on  reality factors in the field and can answer the question: Is this  program achieving its goals within the cost estimates?
In  this assignment, you will create a fictional “how to” guide in  which you will analyze the steps pertinent to effective program  assessment. Specifically, you will:
Explain the parts of the program evaluation, and how one would carry out a program evaluation.
Explain the steps of the program evaluation and what the program evaluator would want to measure / evaluate.
Your fictional “how to” guide is intended to provide a  step-by-step explanation of the components related to evaluating  programs; you will not be conducting an assessment as part of the  assignment. An example of a program evaluation and the research format  is given in the Evaluation Strategies for Human Service Programs (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site..   Your example can be any of the typical health and services areas  including: hospitals, nursing homes, clinic for substance abuse,  counseling clinics, Salvation Army, Red Cross, homes for the homeless,  special school programs, crisis centers and social support. Program  evaluation can include a variety of different research approaches and  may also include acquiring a great deal of data.  As you read the  article Introduction to Program Evaluation for Public Health Programs: A Self-Study Guide (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site.,  keep in mind the information requirements to carry out a program  evaluation. Certainly the connections among program outcomes, the  activities of the program, and consequential outcomes constitute the key  model of any program evaluation. Access the  Introduction to Program Evaluation for Public Health Programs: A Self-Study Guide  (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site. for more information for this assignment.

Locating and Critically Analyzing Primary Research ArticlesDeveloping the proficiency to locate read and evaluate research articles is essential to your success in this doctoral program and your career.

Locating and Critically Analyzing Primary Research ArticlesDeveloping the proficiency to locate read and evaluate research articles is essential to your success in this doctoral program and your career. With this Assignment you have the opportunity to become familiar with the Walden Library by searching the databases reviewing resources and downloading full-text articles. You are asked to think critically as you do this keeping in mind that as a doctoral candidate you must be able to enhance your professions body of knowledge by synthesizing what you have learned into new insights and applying them in meaningful ways within the practice environment (as a DNP-prepared nurse) or engaging in original research (as a PhD-prepared nurse).To prepare:By Day 7To complete:By Wednesday 6/21/17 write a 4-paragraph APA-formatted paper with 4 references from the list below addressing the following:1) Write a 1-paragraph summary of each of the articles you have selected (a total of 2 paragraphs). See Attached PDF for Articles2) Write 1 paragraph thatsynthesizesthe two articles using a scholarly voice.3) Write a final paragraph in which you discuss the differences between summarizing and synthesizing research.P.S. Include an Introduction ending with a purpose statement (e.g. the purpose of this paper is) and a conclusion.Required ReadingsWalden Library. (2014). Publication Comparison Chart. Retrieved from: http://academicguides.waldenu.edu/peerreviewvsscholarlyThis guide discusses three main publication types that you will encounter in the Walden Library: scholarly journals trade publications and popular magazines. It contains information about these publication types and a chart comparing their purpose content audience etc.Eaton S. E. (2010). Reading strategies: Differences between summarizing and synthesizing [Blog post]. Literacy Languages and Leadership. Retrieved from http://drsaraheaton.wordpress.com/2010/09/29/reading-strategies-differneces-between-summarizing-and-synthesizing/The author proposes that critical reading must include using critical thinking to create new information and insights from this information.Institutional Review Board for Ethical Standards in Research: IRB Office Hours and meetings. Retrieved January 15 2014 from http://researchcenter.waldenu.edu/Institutional-Review-Board-for-Ethical-Standards-in-Research.htmThis the Walden online tutorial at the bottom of this page provides information on Waldens Institutional Review Boards (IRBs). These boards are responsible for ensuring that all Walden research studies meet specific ethical and legal criteria.Walden University Library. (2014). Webinar archives. Retrieved from http://academicguides.waldenu.edu/library/webinararchivesIntroduction to the Walden LibraryEvaluating Online ResourcesAn Introduction to Evidence-Based SearchingThe Walden Library webinars provide relevant information on accessing and evaluating scholarly sources. The information on retrieving evidence-based practice sources is especially pertinent to the DNP student.Walden University. (2011). Student publications: Code of conduct. Retrieved from http://catalog.waldenu.edu/Select the current version of the Walden University Student Handbook from the drop-down menu.In the left navigation bar click University Policies and Code of Conduct.Then click Student Conduct and Responsibilities.This link provides you with Student Conduct and Responsibility guidelines to help you develop a better understanding of Walden Universitys expectations.Document: Stages in Critical Reading of Research Articles (PDF) (See attached file)This chart describes the purpose of and questions for six stages of critically reading research articles. Focus on the many activities and questions that make up the critical-reading process. Begin to consider the journal articles and books you read in terms of these criteria.Document: Introduction to Scholarly Writing: Plagiarism and Academic Integrity (PDF) (See attached file)This document supplements the information on plagiarism and academic integrity presented in the related video program.Document: Introduction to Scholarly Writing: Tips for Success (PDF) (See attached file)This document which accompanies the video program of the same title provides resources for improving your scholarly writing and critical-thinking skills.Document: Common APA Style and Formatting Challenges (PDF) (See attached file)This document can be used as a quick reference guide for proper APA style and formatting.Murphy J. (2011). The nursing informatics workforce: who are they and what do they do?.Nursing Economic$ 29(3) 150-153.Collins S. Po-Yin Y. Phillips A. & Kennedy M. K. (2017). Nursing Informatics Competency Assessment for the Nurse Leader.Journal of Nursing Administration 47(4) 212-218. doi:10.1097/NNA.0000000000000467Required MediaLaureate Education (Producer). (2012b). Introduction to scholarly writing: Finding a scholarly voice[Video file]. Retrieved from https://class.waldenu.eduNote: The approximate length of this media piece is 4 minutes.This media program discusses the importance of writing with a scholarly voice distinguishing between a voice that is effective and one that is not and identifying what is needed to develop your own scholarly voice.Laureate Education (Producer). (2012c).Introduction to scholarly writing: Plagiarism and academic integrity[Video file]. Retrieved from https://class.waldenu.eduNote: The approximate length of this media piece is 5 minutes.Scholarly writing requires ethical practice in every phase and form of the process from the drafting of a course paper to the completion of a capstone project. Academic integrity is foundational to all teaching and learning at Walden University. As a Walden student you are required to follow the guidelines of academic integrity as set forth in the Walden Catalog. This media program helps you to do so.Laureate Education (Producer). (2012d).Introduction to scholarly writing: Purpose audience and evidence[Video file]. Retrieved from https://class.waldenu.eduNote: The approximate length of this media piece is 5 minutes.Key concepts related to scholarly writing are introduced in this media program.Laureate Education (Producer). (2012e).Introduction to scholarly writing: Tips for success[Video file]. Retrieved from https://class.waldenu.eduNote: The approximate length of this media piece is 3 minutes.This media program presents tips for becoming a scholarly writer including how to identify fears related to scholarly writing and connect with resources to improve writing skills.

Conceptual Components of TheoryAs with research concepts play a critical role in theory development. Consider for a moment the purpose of theory and its application to nursing practice.

Conceptual Components of TheoryAs with research concepts play a critical role in theory development. Consider for a moment the purpose of theory and its application to nursing practice. At the heart of any theorywhich seeks to describe explain predict or prescribelies the concept or concepts to be explored or addressed. Within the iterative process of theory development concepts must be defined and refined as the relationships between them are identified in order to articulate reality and inform effective practice.To prepare:By Tuesday 6/20/17 post 550 words essay in APA format with 3 references from the list below that include the level one headings as numbered below:1) Discuss the conceptual components of your selected middle range theory as applied to nursing practice. Example: (Kristen Swansons Middle Range Theory of Caring)2) How are these components observed and measured in practice? Provide at least two specific examples.3) Share any insights into how the theory has developed or changed based on the testing of the concepts.Required ReadingsMcEwin M. & Wills E.M. (2014). Theoretical basis for nursing. (4th ed.). Philadelphia PA: Wolters Kluwer Health.Chapter 4 Theory Development: Structuring Conceptual Relationships in Nursing Chapter 4 discusses theory development and examines the components of theories: concepts theoretical statements assumptions and model development. In addition the interrelationship between theory research and practice is examined.Chapter 6 Overview of Grand Nursing Theories Chapter 6 presents an overview of grand theories and how they have influenced nursing practice and research.Gray J.R. Grove S.K. & Sutherland S. (2017). Burns and Groves the practice of nursing research: Appraisal synthesis and generation of evidence (8th ed.). St. Louis MO: Saunders Elsevier.Review Chapter 8 Frameworks Cooper E. (2009). Creating a culture of professional development: A milestone pathway tool for registered nurses. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing 40(11) 501508.Note: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.This article describes how a culture of professional development is found to have a positive impact on nurse retention and satisfaction creating a culture of professional development.Perkins M. Jensen P. Jaccard J. Gollwitzer P. Oettingen G. Pappadopulos E. & Hoagwood K. (2007). Applying theory-driven approaches to understanding and modifying clinicians’ behavior: what do we know? Psychiatric Services 58(3) 342348. doi:10.1176/appi.ps.58.3.342Note: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.This article provides an examination of theory-driven approaches for understanding a clinicians behavior through the analysis of their attitudes subjective norms and perceived behavioral control.Rushing A. M. (2008). The unitary life pattern of persons experiencing serenity in recovery from alcohol and drug addiction. Advances in Nursing Science 31(3) 1982 10.Note: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.This article discusses a research study that utilizes Newmans grand theory as a part of its theoretical framework.Veo P. (2010). Concept mapping for applying theory to nursing practice. Journal for Nurses in Staff Development 26(1) 1722. doi: 10.1097/NND.0b013e3181cc2d6fNote: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.This article explores the use of concept mapping as a tool used to apply theory into daily nursing practices.Woods N. F. & Magyary D. L. (2010). Translational research: Why nursings interdisciplinary collaboration is essential. Research & Theory for Nursing Practice 24(1) 924. doi:10.1891/1541-6577.24.1.9Note: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.This article focuses on the use of translation research within the nursing profession and strategies for nursing leadership to apply translation practices.Optional ResourcesPanniers T. L. Feuerbach R. D. & Soeken K. L. (2003). Methods in informatics: Using data derived from a systematic review of health care texts to develop a concept map for use in the neonatal intensive care setting. Journal of Biomedical Informatics 36(45) 232239. doi:10.1016/j.jbi.2003.09.010Note: You will access this article from the Walden Library databases.

Paula Barneck the newly appointed director of the Lambert Medical Center (LMC) a large metropolitan hospital was reviewing the financial report for the most recent quarter. The hospital had again shown a loss. For the past several years it had been struggling financially.

Paula Barneck the newly appointed director of the Lambert Medical Center (LMC) a large metropolitan hospital was reviewing the financial report for the most recent quarter. The hospital had again shown a loss. For the past several years it had been struggling financially. The financial problems had begun with the introduction of the federal governments new diagnostic-related group (DRG) reimbursement system. Under this system the government mandated fixed fees for specific treatments or illnesses. The fixed fees were supposed to represent what the procedures should cost and differed from the traditional cost objective of the patient day of prior years. Although no formal assessment had been made the general feeling of hospital management was that the DRG reimbursement was hurting LMCs financial state. The increasing popularity of health maintenance organizations (HMOs) and physician provider organizations (PPOs) was also harming the hospitals financial well-being. In HMOs physicians who are employed full time are usually located in a clinic owned by the HMO and subscribers must use these physicians services. In PPOs hospitals provide contracts with a group of physicians in private practice. These physicians usually serve non-PPO patients as well as PPO patients. The PPO patient can select any physician from the list of physicians under contract with the particular PPO. The PPO approach usually offers a greater selection of physicians and tends to preserve the patients traditional freedom of choice. More and more of the hospitals potential patients were joining HMOs and PPOs and unfortunately LMC was not capturing its fair share of the HMO and PPO business. HMOs and PPOs routinely asked for bids on hospital services and provided their business to the lowest bidder. In too many cases LMC had not won that work. Paula had accepted the position of hospital administrator knowing that she was expected to produce dramatic improvements in LMCs financial state. She was convinced that she needed more information about the hospitals product costing methods. Only by having accurate cost information for the various procedures offered by the hospital could she evaluate the effects of DRG reimbursement and the hospitals bidding strategy. Paula requested a meeting with Eric Rose the hospitals controller. Their conversation follows: PAULA:Eric as you know we recently lost a bid on some laboratory tests that would be performed on a regular basis for a local HMO. In fact I was told by the director of the HMO that we had the highest bid of the three submitted. I know the identity of the other two hospitals that submitted bids and I have a hard time believing that their costs for these tests are any lower than ours. Describe exactly how we determine the cost of these lab procedures. 7-2 ERIC:First we classify all departments as either revenue-producing centers or service centers. Next the costs of the service centers are allocated to the revenue producing centers. The costs directly traceable to the revenue-producing centers are then added to the allocated costs to obtain the total cost of operating the revenue-producing center. This total cost is divided by the total revenues of the revenue-producing center to obtain a cost-to-charges ratio. Finally the cost of a particular procedure is computed by multiplying the charge for that procedure by the cost-tocharges ratio. PAULA:Let me see if I understand. The costs of laundry housekeeping maintenance and other service departments are allocated to all of the revenue-producing departments. Lets assume that the lab receives $100 000 as its share of these allocated costs. The $100 000 is then added to the direct costslets assume these are also $100 000to obtain total operating costs of $200 000. If the laboratory earns revenues of $250 000 the cost-to-charges ratio is 0.80 ($200 000/$250 000). Finally if I want to know the cost of a particular lab procedure say a blood test for which we normally charge $20 then all I do is multiply the cost-to-charges ratio of 0.8 by $20 to obtain the cost of $16. Am I right? ERIC:Absolutely. In the laboratory testing bid that we just lost our bid was at cost as computed using our cost-to-charges formula. Perhaps the other hospitals are bidding below their cost to capture the business. PAULA:Eric I dont agree. The cost-to-charges ratio is a traditional approach for costing hospital products but Im afraid that it is no longer useful. Given the new environment in which were operating we need more accurate product costing information. We need accuracy to improve our bidding to help us assess and deal with the new DRG reimbursement system and to evaluate the mix of services we offer. The cost-to-charges ratio approach backs into the product cost. It is indirect and inaccurate. Some procedures require more labor more materials and more expensive equipment than others. The cost-to-charges approach doesnt reflect these potential differences. ERIC:Well Im willing to change the cost accounting system so that it meets our needs. Do you have any suggestions? PAULA:Yes. Im in favor of a more direct computation of product costs. Allocating support service costs to the revenue-producing departments is only the first stage in product costing. We do need to allocate these support service costs to the producing departmentsbut we need to be certain that we are allocating them in the right way. We also need to go a step further and assign the costs accumulated in the revenue producing departments to individual products. The costs directly traceable to each product should be identified and assigned directly to those products; indirect costs can be assigned through one or more overhead rates. The base for assigning the overhead costs should be associated with their incurrence. If at all possible allocations should reflect the usage of support services by the revenue-producing departments; moreover the same criterion should govern the assignment of overhead costs to the products within the department. ERIC:Sounds like an interesting challenge. With over 30 000 products a job-order costing system would be too burdensome and costly. I think some system can be developed however that will do essentially what you want. PAULA:Good. Listen for our next meeting come prepared to brief me on why and how you allocate these service department costs to the revenue-producing departments. I think this is a 7-3 critical step in accurate product costing. I also want to know how you propose to assign the costs accumulated in each revenue-producing department to that departments products. As Eric mentally reviewed his meeting with Paula he realized that the failure of bids could be attributable to inaccurate cost assignments. Because of this possibility Eric decided to do some additional investigation to see if the cost-to-charges ratio method of costing services was responsible. Eric pulled the current years budgeted data from his files. He found the following data. The number of departments and the budget have been reduced for purposes of simplification. Support Departments Revenue Departments Administrative Laundry Janitorial Laboratory Nursing Overhead $20 000 $75 000 $50 000 $43 000 $150 000 Employees 1 4 7 8 20 Pounds of laundry 50 200 400 1 000 4 000 Square feet 1 000 1 200 500 5 000 20 000 Support department costs are allocated using the direct method. Eric decided to compute the costs of three different lab tests using the cost-to-charges ratio and then recompute them using a more direct method as suggested by Paula. By comparing the unit costs under each approach he could evaluate the cost-estimating ability of the cost-tocharges ratio. The three tests selected for study were the blood count test (Test B) cholesterol test (Test C) and a chemical blood analysis (Test CB). After careful observation of the three tests Eric concluded that the consumption of the resources of the laboratory could be associated with the relative amount of time taken by each test. Based on the amount of time needed to perform each test Eric developed relative value units (RVUs) and associated the consumption
of materials and labor with these units. The RVUs for each test and the cost per RVU for materials and labor are as follows: Test RVUs Material per RVU Labor per RVU B 1 $2.00 $2.00 C 2 2.50 2.00 CB 3 1.00 2.00 Eric also concluded that the pool of overhead costs collected within the laboratory should be applied using RVUs. (He was convinced that RVU was a good activity driver for overhead.) The laboratorys expected RVUs for the year were 22 500. The laboratory usually performs an equal number of the three tests over a year. This year was no exception. Eric also noted that the hospital usually priced its services so that revenues exceeded costs by a specified percentage. Based on the past total costs of the laboratory this pricing strategy had led to the following fees for the three blood tests: Test B Test C Test CB Fees charged $5.00 $19.33 $22.00 7-4 Required: 1. Allocate the costs of the support departments to the two revenue-producing departments using the direct method. 2. Assuming that the three blood tests are the only tests performed in the laboratory compute the cost-to-charges ratio (total costs of the laboratory divided by the laboratorys total revenues). 3. Using the cost-to-charges ratio computed in Requirement 2 estimate the cost per test for each blood test. 4. Compute the cost per test for each test using RVUs. 5. Which unit costthe one using the cost-to-charges ratio or the one using RVUsdo you think is the most accurate? Explain. 6. Assume that Lambert Medical Center has been requested by an HMO to bid on Test CB. Using a 5 percent markup prepare the bid using the cost computed in Requirement 3. Repeat using the cost prepared in Requirement 4. Suppose that anyone who bids $20 or less will win the bid. Discuss the implications of costing accuracy on the hospitals problems with its bidding practices.