| Assignment Criteria |
A(92-100%)
Outstanding or highest level of performance |
B(84-91%)
Very good or high level of performance |
C(76-83%)
Competent or satisfactory level of performance |
F(0-75%)
Poor or failing or unsatisfactory level of performance |
Pts. |
| Research question(20 points) |
Fully describes the research question.(18-20 points) |
Partially describes the research question(17 points) |
Minimally describes the research question.(15-16 points) |
Does not describe the research question.(0-14 points) |
/20 |
| Design of the study.(20 points) |
Fully describes the design of the study(18-20 points) |
Partially describes the design of the study(17 points) |
Minimally describes the design of the study(15-16 points) |
Does not describe the design of the study(0-14 points) |
/20 |
| Sample/ population of the study(25 points) |
Fully describes the sample used in the study.(23-25 points) |
Partially describes the sample used in the study.(21-22 points) |
Minimally describes the sample used in the study.(19-20 points) |
Does not describe the sample used in the study.(0-18 points) |
/25 |
| Data collection methods(25 points) |
Fully describes the data collection method used in the study.(23-25 points) |
Partially describes the data collection method used in the study.(21-22 points) |
Minimally describes the data collection method used in the study.(19-20 points) |
Does not describe the data collection method used in the study.(0-18 points) |
/25 |
| Limitations(20 points) |
Fully describes the limitations found in the study.(18-20 points) |
Partially describe the limitations found in the study.(17 points) |
Minimally describe the limitations found in the study.(15-16 points) |
Does not describe the limitations found in the study.(0-14 points) |
/20 |
| Findings(25 points) |
Fully describes the findings of the study.(23-25 points) |
Partially describes the findings of the study.(21-22points) |
Minimally describes the findings of the study.(19-20 points) |
Does not describe the findings of the study.(0-18 points) |
/25 |
| Summary(25 points) |
Summarizes study and states rationale for whether a change in practice is warranted(23-25 points) |
Partially summarizes study and states rationale for whether a change in practice is warranted.(21-22 points) |
Minimally summarizes study and states rationale for whether a change in practice is warranted.(19-20 points) |
Does not summarize study and does not give rationale for whether a change in practice is warranted.(0-18 points) |
/25 |
| Article selection(20 points) |
Closely related to research question, peer-reviewed. Single primary research study that produces a high level of evidence, for example, (randomized controlled trial, clinical trial or cohort trial) reported in the article. Uploads working permalink to CCN Library Article.(18-20 points) |
Mostly related to research question and peer-reviewedOR case study reported in the article.
Uploads working permalink to CCN Library Article.
(17 points) |
Somewhat related to research question and is a nursing source but not peer-reviewed OR opinion or editorial reported in the article.Uploads working permalink to CCN Library Article.
(15-16 points) |
Not related to research questionOR questionable source, but not peer-reviewed OR not an article but is instead a website or other publication. OR
Does not upload working permalink to CCN Library Article.
(0-14 points) |
/20 |
| Grammar, punctuation, and spelling/ APA formatting(20 points) |
No more than 0–3 errors in grammar, punctuation, APA, and spelling.(18-20 points) |
No more than4–6 errors in grammar, punctuation, APA, and spelling(17 points) |
No more than 7-9 errors in grammar, punctuation, APA, and spelling(15-16 points) |
More than10 errors(0-14 points) |
/20 |
| Total Points = 200 |
|
__ / 200 points |